The Old Mill Creamery
Restored 1830s mill dairy; house ice cream, bottled milk, farm treats; classic day-off dessert stop.
Susky Says
Take a country drive to The Old Mill Creamery for a scoop of ice cream and a simple rural outing. It’s a cheerful stop to pair with back-road scenery, family time, or an evening treat.
Ice cream
Been here?
We keep this guide honest by fixing it when it's wrong. If the hours changed, the place closed, or we got something backwards, tell us. It takes a minute.
Nearby
Also in Mifflinburg
Blue Moose Events
Former Moose Lodge; public by reservation; BYOB beer/wine; multi-event parties.
DC Coffee & Tea Co.
Local coffee + breakfast/paninis with vegetarian and GF options. Mifflinburg day-off café hang.
Elias Center for the Performing Arts
Historic 1806 building restored as Mifflinburg’s arts hub; curated listening-room songwriter shows and community concerts.